Board logo

Redundancy
nick205 - 24/10/14 at 10:23 AM



Just completed the joyless task of making someone redundant. Second time I've had to do this in my career and it really is horrible. Thankfully the employee made it relatively straightforward and we have a good HR consultant to help ensure it's done correctly.

Not sure why I'm posting this TBH, maybe it helps to off load


Irony - 24/10/14 at 10:48 AM

Doing it is just rubbish. I feel worse if the person has kids, mortgage etc.


Slimy38 - 24/10/14 at 11:30 AM

I had to go through the process with one of my old teams, it's probably the worst thing I've had to do. As you say you're pretty much destroying their livelihood.

Good HR is always a bonus, you can get in trouble if you get the process wrong.


Brook_lands - 24/10/14 at 12:36 PM

It's never good especially when it is through no fault of the person being made redundant.

I always used to do it on a Monday rather than a Friday and tell them that their full time job this week was to get another job, better they get out doing something than stew over it all weekend.

While it might seem like it at the time its not the end of the world, all the ones I have had to make redundant that I know about did OK if not better afterwards.

Been made redundant once myself, and to be honest it was a good thing, much happier now even if not as well paid.


r1_pete - 24/10/14 at 12:56 PM

Its certainly not nice, especially when you know they are the sole bread winner and have family, done it too often to count now, it never gets easy...

Wish someone would do it to me mind.........


coozer - 24/10/14 at 02:00 PM

When it happened to me it made my blood boil, the tosser telling seemed to be really smug, could hardly contain his grin and I felt really let down. Even the hr wifey said he was horrible...

Even now years later in hindsight it still makes me cringe....


bi22le - 24/10/14 at 02:42 PM

In the last 10 mins I have been told I was not successful in getting a job I really wanted. I am employed and paid ok but really want out.

I feel like I have just been made redundent, totally gutted.

The job hunting process is awful.

have a good weekend.


craig1410 - 24/10/14 at 02:54 PM

If it's any consolation, in my experience people who are made redundant almost always end up happier and more successful in their next job. Perhaps a combination of reasons such as:

1. The company they were working for is probably not in great shape.
2. They get a payout which can be significant depending on years worked.
3. They get a kick in their complacency which can make a huge difference to outcomes.
4. They get to work for a company who is hiring - usually a better bet than one which is making people redundant.
5. Best bit - they get to leave behind a load of baggage which accumulates over the years in any job. Fresh start!

So, it's by no means all bad - I've seen this pattern numerous times over the years and I always try to give this positive message to any affected people. I also do all I can to help them find new jobs (e.g.. LinkedIn referrals, introductions to people in my network, just a chat etc.)

Hope this helps,
Craig.

[Edited on 24/10/2014 by craig1410]


snapper - 24/10/14 at 04:55 PM

I don't understand why more companies go for voluntary first
Give those who are truly pi55ed off the chance to go and leave those who want a job still in with a chance


nick205 - 24/10/14 at 04:59 PM

quote:
Originally posted by craig1410
If it's any consolation, in my experience people who are made redundant almost always end up happier and more successful in their next job. Perhaps a combination of reasons such as:

1. The company they were working for is probably not in great shape.
2. They get a payout which can be significant depending on years worked.
3. They get a kick in their complacency which can make a huge difference to outcomes.
4. They get to work for a company who is hiring - usually a better bet than one which is making people redundant.
5. Best bit - they get to leave behind a load of baggage which accumulates over the years in any job. Fresh start!

So, it's by no means all bad - I've seen this pattern numerous times over the years and I always try to give this positive message to any affected people. I also do all I can to help them find new jobs (e.g.. LinkedIn referrals, introductions to people in my network, just a chat etc.)

Hope this helps,
Craig.

[Edited on 24/10/2014 by craig1410]



1. That's partly what made it difficult. The company grew by nearly 25% in the last 12 months. However it was in a totally new direction with new products. The redundancy came about as part of a refocus on what makes the company profitable. The product line with which the person was involved was made obsolete and there was simply no role left for the employee.

2. 22 months service so no redundancy payout.

3. No complacency involved, just no role left.

4 & 5 Can only wish the best for the future I guess.


twybrow - 24/10/14 at 05:06 PM

At a previous employer I had to do 3 rounds in my team in 3 years. The worst was making a chap redundant 3 weeks before Christmas, and he had 6 kids! But he went on to find a much better paying job, and the company paid him out handsomely, so not all bad in the end. It is not nice to have to give that news though - a low point in my career for sure.


AntonUK - 24/10/14 at 06:18 PM

While I'm currently a manager I'm not a manager of direct members of staff. My next career target is to have direct reports. But it is stories like this that make me think twice.

Closest I came was having to let a great team of contractors go that we we had kept constantly employed constantly for 3 years, Worse of all it was 3 days before christmas.


femster87 - 24/10/14 at 06:27 PM

quote:
Originally posted by bi22le
In the last 10 mins I have been told I was not successful in getting a job I really wanted. I am employed and paid ok but really want out.

I feel like I have just been made redundent, totally gutted.

The job hunting process is awful.

have a good weekend.




Cheer up. There are more jobs out there.


TimC - 24/10/14 at 07:45 PM

I've had to have those conversations more times than I care to think about. The one that always sticks in my mind was 'Stretch', a genuinely enormous guy. By the time he left the room his shoulders had slumped and his head dropped to the extent that she looked like a little boy. No fun at all.


metro6r4 - 25/10/14 at 12:51 PM

having just been made redundant myself I know how hard it is but if the employer is respectful about how they do it it can take a lot of the sting out of it. Hopefully the guy can find a new job quickly. With my redundancy the firm I was working for took the Mikey but I had the last laugh as I got a job with the competition the day after my redundancy went through on more money. I know its not always like this but like I said if you handled the situation in a respectful manor it makes things easier for all concerned