Board logo

Arrrgghhhh Barnet Clutch Plates
G.Man - 28/11/06 at 01:03 PM

Well, stripped my car today to find the barnett clutch plates have disintegrated, and the resulting carnage has destroyed the clutch basket...

Bearing in mind these lasted less than 50 miles, and the stock plates lasted MUCH longer, i cannot recommend staying away from these enough...

Looking like a new billet clutch basket and upgraded clutch from muzzy's is the way forward...

Only $1000 + shipping gutted


DIY Si - 28/11/06 at 01:07 PM

Oh, good (in a way for me) timing, as I'm about to strip and replace my clutch. I was looking at the barnett clutchs too! Can you not get a cheaper billet basket from anywhere, and are they needed in a bec? (I'm trying to keep cost down) Have Barnett said anything about the ridiculous life of the parts yet?


G.Man - 28/11/06 at 01:10 PM

I dont think the billet basket is required, but if you have a zx12r I highly recommend looking at the muzzys clutch upgrade, as it massively improves oil flow to the clutch, and my clutch mainly appeared to have worn due to lack of oil flow..

Havent spoken to barnett, not worth the effort...

The Muzzy clutch upgrade kit includes plates, springs, clutch centre (crossdrilled to improve oil flow) and a few other parts...

worth $324 of anyones money after i paid $200+ for just the barnett clutch plates and springs!!!!


tks - 28/11/06 at 01:31 PM

Thats a good point!!

Where did i ever read that new plates needs to be left overnight in fresh bike oil?? Before fitment!!

in you setup you mount them dry and they hardly will get oiled right??
since the fact that they wear only nothing to become unusable..

Tks

[Edited on 28/11/06 by tks]


Hellfire - 28/11/06 at 01:43 PM

Just a point worth noting but stock clutch steels for the ZX12R are available in 1.4mm, 1.6mm and 2.0mm thickness IIRC. Might be worth checking the thickness of the ones you have and maybe replace all steels with 2.0mm

Phil


Phil.J - 28/11/06 at 01:47 PM

I've had no issues with Barnett plates in my dry sumped GSX-R engined hillclimb single seater(200hp + soft slicks + tyre warming + double driven). Barnett springs yes, I do need to change them twice a year or the clutch slips.


G.Man - 28/11/06 at 04:14 PM

Yes the plates were soaked in oil before fitment, not it isnt down to the thickness as it came with new frictions and steels and the clutch stack was measured..

The problem is that the material came away from the plates due to heat buildup.. now bear in mind, these are sold as race plates, yet the quality of them is not a patch on stock kawasaki plates...

The original zx12r did have some clutch lubrication issues, and they are not fed from the dry sump, they are fed from an oilway in the gearbox input shaft... this spits oil into the inside of the clutch where centrifugal force does the rest...

Sadly the kawasaki zx12r A1 was not very good at this and now kawasaki sell replacement parts that distribute the oil better...

The stock plates lasted over a 1000km, the barnet ones lasted less than 50km...

Please credit me with some intelligence as an ex bsb technician... and the fact that the plates come with a big label that says these must be soaked in oil for at least one hour before installation...

BTW. these plates are the new material they have just started selling in the last 6 months, they are red rather than brown... so all reports of older materials may be invalid, and I have to say, i was surprised at how thin the friction material was compared to what was left on the original plates... it was no thicker than a cornflake packet!



PS. I will post some pics of the stock plates that came out, and the barnett plates that came out when i get a chance...



[Edited on 28/11/06 by G.Man]


Hellfire - 28/11/06 at 04:41 PM

It may be worth getting in touch with Barnett and informing them, especially if they are a new product. Could be a manufacturing defect or inferior material. They may have had loads of complaints about them already. You never know, they may even reimburse you. You've got nothing to lose..............

Phil

[Edited on 28-11-06 by Hellfire]


fesycresy - 28/11/06 at 07:46 PM

Perhaps you're slipping the clutch like a big jesse ?

Keep it on the cam


G.Man - 28/11/06 at 08:00 PM

Only to pull away, and I wasnt driving when it blew..

so I cannot say how it was being driven.. grrr

Anyway, its going back together with updated kawasaki parts and I will cross drill the clutch hub to improve the lubrication to the plates...

Sadly the clutch explosion has cracked the clutch casing which is magnesium so cannot be welded... Looks like a job for JB Weld epoxy then..

Chris, sorry yes, the olduns were green not brown, my mistake

sigh


G.Man - 4/1/07 at 06:23 AM

Just to follow up on this..

If you have an A1 zx12r there is uprated clutch parts available (basket and hub)

Apparently they don't provide enough oil to the clutch plates with the stock parts...

Grrrrr


Guess this is why the barnett clutch disintegrated taking the basket with it...

Anyway, useful info..

Now have all the new parts, only £500


clutch_kick - 4/1/07 at 12:20 PM

Ok so while on the subject ... I may have found a 2002 ZX-12r 'B' model engine locally. Any pro's/con's G.Man?


Hellfire - 4/1/07 at 12:40 PM

In 2002, the ZX12 got a major revamp. These are the second generation or B models. Engine improvements included a heavier balanced crank for smoother riding as well as oval throttle pulleys for smoother acceleration. IIRC, the clutch issues on the A1 models were quickly resolved by Kawasaki, possibly on the A2 model.

Phil


G.Man - 4/1/07 at 12:48 PM

quote:
Originally posted by clutch_kick
Ok so while on the subject ... I may have found a 2002 ZX-12r 'B' model engine locally. Any pro's/con's G.Man?


Thats about the best model, except you will need a bonneville box from muzzies to remove the speed restriction..

http://www.muzzys.com/MZPM-K12/index.html

reiterate what hellfire said...


clutch_kick - 4/1/07 at 01:01 PM

Right. I'm not really interested in going upto 300km/h in an open cockpit, just going round corners without braking

So if i get a good deal, i go for it then i guess. Should keep me busy over the summer, refurbishing the donor parts and engine, and get building next winter.

*** Grrrrr ... I think faster than i can type!!

[Edited on 4/1/07 by clutch_kick]


Hellfire - 4/1/07 at 01:09 PM

From what I have read on the subject, the Bonneville box may actually be a waste of money and it's doubtful whether it works at all.

Phil


G.Man - 5/1/07 at 07:45 AM

quote:
Originally posted by Hellfire
From what I have read on the subject, the Bonneville box may actually be a waste of money and it's doubtful whether it works at all.

Phil


Source?

Clutch kick

you need it if you need max rpm in top gear, ie about 130mph


Hellfire - 5/1/07 at 10:42 AM

Apologies - my post is incorrect and as some of my more recent posts have been misconstrued lately, allow me to point out that this was in no way a dig at the manufacturer

The statement I made was in relation to ZX12R models other than 2001 to 2003 models ie. 2000 & 2004 onwards (which wasn’t clear from my post – although it probably looks like I’m back pedalling now)

As you know, the only model ZX12R that was derestricted as stock, is the A1 model. All other models since then have an imposed 186mph speed limit restrictor built into the ECU. The Bonneville Box is available for the A2, B1 & B2 models only and de-restricts the speed limiter in 6th gear by fooling the ECU into thinking that the bike is going slower than it actually is. So on these models, the Bonneville Box does work.

Just out of interest, apparently a yellow-box can also achieve the same thing by reducing the speedo readout. What seems to be a bit of a grey area though, is where the ECU gets its signal from and whereabouts you connect the yellow-box in relation to the ECU and speedo to achieve this.

In the real world, a Bonneville Box will give you maybe an extra 10mph max, when you’re flat out in sixth. Now I don’t know about you but apart from a run on a dyno at Holeshot, I have never seen 12,750rpm in sixth gear. Even if you had the box fitted, you’d probably run out of straight road in a seven before its effects were felt and therefore IMO, it is not worth the money. Besides, think of all that extra weight

Phil


clutch_kick - 5/1/07 at 12:24 PM

Hold on ... what does the ECU restriction use, Speed readout, or RPM in 6th Gear?


Hellfire - 5/1/07 at 12:51 PM

quote:
Originally posted by clutch_kick
Hold on ... what does the ECU restriction use, Speed readout, or RPM in 6th Gear?


Therein lies the grey area. I have heard that it uses the speedo pick-up to activate the limiter, so if you connect the yellow-box between the pick-up and the ECU, in theory it can be fooled. That's only what I've heard though, I know next to nothing about electrics. It may be the speedo, the gear position sensor, the RPM's or a combination of any of those.

Phil


clutch_kick - 5/1/07 at 01:50 PM

Well if it is a combination of signals, and the ECU specifically needs to know that it is in Sixth, then all you have to do is eliminate the little bugger telling the ecu that you're in sixth.

It's a pity that Tuneboy in Australia do not have the access to map the Kawasaki ECU's. A friend of mine has the software and tunes out his triumph speed triple with it, and it is an excellent peice of kit. The Stock ECU is programmable using the Tune-edit software and cable.

Has anyone looked into using the Speed Triple 3 cylinder engine in a BEC?


G.Man - 5/1/07 at 03:55 PM

Hellfire, you are of course correct, very rare its gonna see max rpm in top...

Mine is an A1 and they are restricted in output... trumpets won't flow enough air, reduced advance... that means they dont quite have enough grunt to get to 200mph...

However, the mods I have done have more than negated this... and I have new trumpets..



Didnt know about the 2004 onwards, but I will beleive you, as I have no reason to doubt, you know your stuff..

Clutch_kick the boneville box changes the gear position indicator so the ecu thinks you are in 5th...


G.Man - 5/1/07 at 04:27 PM

Forgot to say, bitch slapped the car back together today, new clutch is peachy and seems good at the moment... fingers crossed...

2.5 hours to clean the dry sump pan and engine out, fit entire new clutch assembly, change filter, refil oil and start...

Was quite proud of myself... never managed a clutch change and sump clean that fast when i was changing a BSB slipper.. and boy did they blow up a lot...

Not as funny tho as when my rider was on the line at mallory, went to pull away at the start, and threw the chain out the back of the bike...

He was like, this darn clutch, and I said, I think you will be needing a new one of these... holding the chain the marshall brought to me... lmao

Rare to see an entire link snap, not the riveted one, a normal link... must have been a dodgy one...


clutch_kick - 6/1/07 at 11:32 AM

Ok so instead of spending money on the bonneville box ... what if the ECU never knew it got to 6th? sneaky git hehehe


G.Man - 6/1/07 at 01:39 PM

You will have to be very sneaky, as you cannot just disconnect the gear position indicator..


Hellfire - 6/1/07 at 02:20 PM

Lots of ZX12R owners have tried this mod and looped 6th gear into 5th. Some have said it works, others say it doesn't. The fact of the matter is, that nobody can provide any proof either way, such as dyno printouts etc. If there was conclusive proof that it worked, everyone would be doing it by now but for some reason or another they aren't, which leads me to suspect it doesn't work.

If you want to try it for yourself, drop me a U2U and I'll give you the info on what to do.

Phil


G.Man - 6/1/07 at 02:28 PM

From what I know the g/bk and the g/w from the ecu which goes to the gp switch are the 6th and 5th gear wires...

It would make sense to cut the g/bk and scotchlock it to the g/w

On the switch lead the wires are y/g and g/r respectively...


Hellfire - 6/1/07 at 02:40 PM

quote:
Originally posted by Hellfire
blah........blah......blah........

If you want to try it for yourself, drop me a U2U and I'll give you the info on what to do.


.......... Or just follow G-Mans instructions above .

Phil


clutch_kick - 6/1/07 at 05:48 PM

right let me just buy an engine first. Then we'll see, the maltese have a very odd talent of getting around things very cheaply. Like taxes for example.


G.Man - 6/1/07 at 08:37 PM

Let us know how it goes..

No need for it on my A1


clutch_kick - 6/1/07 at 10:55 PM

Don't hold your breath i'm a chronic-procrastinator.


Hellfire - 6/1/07 at 11:03 PM

JUST DO IT You know it makes sense....

Phil