Board logo

What engine
jonah - 29/10/07 at 07:37 PM

Hi All,

I'm just about to start my BEC locost. I've been going around in circles about what engine kit to go for. I nearly bought a damaged busa a few weeks ago but decided not to because the head had damage.

Can anybody help? Cost is a big factor but not the only factor that will decided what I go for, I want a very fast car!!! (in normal car terms) not driveability or a good motorway car, but i don't want to go down the turbo road. I would like to buy and fit something as a standard unit.

I've been looking at the obvious, R1, ZX9R, blade etc. but how do you all decided what to go for? What's the ultimate deciding factor?

All coments more than welcome.

Thanks

Jonah


RichardK - 29/10/07 at 07:42 PM

Not sure where you are from but you could try Malc from Yorkshire Engines, he posts on here so do a search and you should find him and drop him a u2u, always gets good comments about the stuff he sells and good customer service from what I hear.

Regards

Rich


gordon - 29/10/07 at 07:51 PM

Hi
good to see you gone for bec no matter what you go for it will feel fast. I went for zx9 can be brought for little money and are a strong engine.


Jon Ison - 29/10/07 at 08:22 PM

I would use the following formula to decide if I was contemplating a new build.



£££'s v BHP = ZX12


fesycresy - 29/10/07 at 08:49 PM

quote:
Originally posted by Jon Ison
I would use the following formula to decide if I was contemplating a new build.



£££'s v BHP = ZX12



Where did you got to school ?

£££'s v BHP = R1


Guinness - 29/10/07 at 08:55 PM

Ison, Fesy, detention.

£ x BHP = ZZR1100 ! £250 for a kit and 147 bhp as standard? That's £1.70 per horse!

But assuming you want a modern fuel injected engine with minimum miles on it, easy parts availability I'd go ZX12 now too!



Mike


Jon Ison - 29/10/07 at 08:58 PM

quote:
Originally posted by fesycresy
quote:
Originally posted by Jon Ison
I would use the following formula to decide if I was contemplating a new build.



£££'s v BHP = ZX12



Where did you got to school ?

£££'s v BHP = R1





oi i lerned toooo speel as skool 2


Dangle_kt - 29/10/07 at 09:11 PM

some big BHP engines need dry sumping, which costs serious cash. Do a search to find out whatr you can/can not use without sorting it.

Blade/r1/busa/zx9r are the commen ones - and these will hold there value better than zzr1100 or other less commenly used engines.

Don't overlook loom, carbs (or TB's), lock sets (some newer engines will only work with original keys), ECU's. clocks. some of these go for stupid cash, so look into each engine properly.

I chose an older fireblade engine, as ancilleries are cheap as are the engines if it ever goes pop, plus it will be worth a bit if I ever sold up.

r1 was my second choice, but it would have cost more. I am on track to get the entire BEC transplant includng prop, cradle, clocks etc for £1000 all in.

which will be a lot of bang for my buck.


jonah - 29/10/07 at 10:21 PM

quote:
Originally posted by Dangle_kt
some big BHP engines need dry sumping, which costs serious cash. Do a search to find out whatr you can/can not use without sorting it.

Blade/r1/busa/zx9r are the commen ones - and these will hold there value better than zzr1100 or other less commenly used engines.




This is the type of thing i'm after, I really want the best for my money without being caught out somewhere at a later date with dry sumps and locked out ecu's.

Are there any hard a fast rules about what needs dry sumping etc. ??

Thanks all

Keep them coming...

Jonah


Dangle_kt - 30/10/07 at 12:25 PM

quote:
Originally posted by jonah
quote:
Originally posted by Dangle_kt
some big BHP engines need dry sumping, which costs serious cash. Do a search to find out whatr you can/can not use without sorting it.

Blade/r1/busa/zx9r are the commen ones - and these will hold there value better than zzr1100 or other less commenly used engines.




This is the type of thing i'm after, I really want the best for my money without being caught out somewhere at a later date with dry sumps and locked out ecu's.

Are there any hard a fast rules about what needs dry sumping etc. ??

Thanks all

Keep them coming...

Jonah


I'd use the search function to find out, as some are questionable - some say it needs sumping, some dont. I know that the BUSA defo needs it, and as far as I am concerned i will not be dry sumping my blade engine as lots have managed without with no issues. Id dotn want to comment on anymore, as misinformation is the last thing you need!


ChrisGamlin - 30/10/07 at 12:38 PM

Personally I still think the early injected (02-03) R1 engine takes a lot of beating for performance, reliability and ease of install, although the ZX12 is also a good candidate. The ZX9 and blades are also good choices although having upgraded from a carbed blade to an 03 R1 I can't really see any reason to pick an older blade (or a ZX9) over the R1 unless you're really trying to keep the budget right down, or are planning on competing in a specific race class like RGB.

Whatever way you go though, if you don't want hassle during the install then I'd suggest not trying to be a pioneer with the latest engine with 10bhp more, and pick an engine that's been installed regularly by others. Its also worth remembering that some older engines may look cheap for the power on paper, but often you can't get off-the-shelf items for them like you can with blades / R1s / ZX9s etc, which cancels out a lot of the initial cost saving needing bespoke manifolds etc made up.