Board logo

Master Cylinder 'Brands'...
scootz - 20/5/12 at 04:11 PM

I need to get three non-integral 0.625 MC's. I'm mulling over whether there will be a (real world) difference between a branded MC and an unbranded one.

Do I buy three of THESE for the same price as one of THESE.

Or will I (possibly not) live to regret it!?


mookaloid - 20/5/12 at 05:04 PM

Been thinking hard about this - and it's really tricky

I really don't know

Probably need to know more about the application


scootz - 20/5/12 at 05:14 PM

Sub 300kg's bike-engined reverse-trike.


britishtrident - 20/5/12 at 05:20 PM

No brainer if the seals weep on the cheaper cylinder all you need to do is fit a Girling repair kit.


mookaloid - 20/5/12 at 05:21 PM

quote:
Originally posted by scootz
Sub 300kg's bike-engined reverse-trike.


That makes the decision a lot easier - as BT says


scootz - 20/5/12 at 06:02 PM

Roger... thanks chaps!


dave r - 20/5/12 at 07:58 PM

no worse than using a donor item, thats already worn out


scootz - 22/5/12 at 11:18 AM

Ordered the a ebay 'non-brands'.

They arrived today and it seems they were once 'branded'!!! Wonder what name was rubbed off...



tasmod - 23/5/12 at 07:20 AM

Ooooo. Not to rain on your parade but that smacks of 'seconds'.

Manufacturer quality control says that cylinder bore incorrect or that assembled unit won't hold steady pressure long enough to pass test. Grind off name and add to rejects.
Someone comes along and buys rejects and puts on ebay.

I may be completely wrong though.


scootz - 23/5/12 at 08:05 AM

Don't worry... there was never any sunshine on my parade.

I'll give em a go and see how they stand up!


CNHSS1 - 23/5/12 at 02:28 PM

or one of the named brands has sold their old tools to AN Other, whom produce cheaper versions in left of azbekistan, and gring off the name from the old cast tool

or the named versions are made by same factory in outer mongolia, but they have to remove name to flog on?

or could just be ebay crap


Davey D - 23/5/12 at 02:58 PM

The master cylinders i was supplied by MNR for my VortX are like that with the original name ground off them !


phelpsa - 23/5/12 at 06:10 PM

IMO the wilwood ones are pretty poor quality. Monumental amounts of pedal dead band due to rod free play and foot valve leakage, and one seal failure after less than 300 miles. I had started to wonder whether a single OEM master cylinder and a PRV would have been a better solution!

AP Racing mcyls on order

[Edited on 23-5-12 by phelpsa]